Baking bread is relaxing (and delicious!). Find out today the differences between Lean and Enriched Dough.
Last week I had the opportunity to be in Kansas and learn all about wheat and bread basics. Today I want to share with you some basic tips when it comes to dough and the breads they produce. Let’s look at Lean dough and Enriched dough. Do you know the difference? No? Maybe you know it like this – soft bread and hard crusty bread. You certainly know the difference between those. Soft breads are those breads that we often use for sandwiches, babka, cinnamon rolls, brioche or even monkey bread. It’s has a soft, almost pillowy type interior with an equally soft crust. Hard crusty breads are your french baguettes , pizza crust, or no knead crusty breads.
Last week, while in the baking class, we referred to these types of doughs by their culinary names – lean or enriched. So what’s the difference? I mean they all have flour, yeast, water and salt – what’s left? Plenty!
Lean Dough
A lean dough is a dough that is normally only 4 ingredients with little to no fat or sugar. Typically it’s just flour, salt, water and yeast. It can have sugar/honey or even oil in it (think perhaps pizza dough) but it’s such a small amount. What’s produced is a dough that, when baked, has a crusty exterior with an interior that is more airy (has some holes). The dough, when baked, has a hollow sound when baked. Crusty breads made with a lean dough are often ones you’ll see for pizzas, artisan breads, baguettes and so forth. These are typically used say for crostini, swooping up sauces at the bottom of your plate (mmmm love hot buttered crusty bread and pasta sauce!) or garlic bread for example.
Lean doughs aren’t mixed for long periods of time and often can be made with the “No Knead” method where you simply dump all of the ingredients in a bowl, mix and cover to ferment and rise.
Here are some of my lean dough recipes:
Enriched Dough
An enriched dough starts off like a lean dough except it has a higher concentration of fats, sugar and dairy. This dough produces a super soft interior with a tender crumb. It’s often termed ‘billowy” as the dough is so soft that it just billows and pulls apart so tenderly. So why does the addition of fat or dairy to a dough make the outcome so much different from lean? Well, let me put my nerd glasses on and explain it. Fat, whether it’s from milk, butter or eggs, tenderizes the dough by coating and shortening the gluten strands. Fat also helps to retard the yeast activity requiring a longer fermentation time which ultimately leads to a dough with much more flavor. Now the difference is, by adding the fat, dairy, sugar to the dough, it tends to make the dough heavier. Ever had a cinnamon roll that was ginormous and you swear weighed 6 pounds? Well that’s because it’s made with an enriched dough.
To make enriched dough you have 3 different methods to mix it – straight, high fat or sponge.
- Straight means you dump everything into the bowl at the same time and mix away. You would use this when your enriched dough doesn’t have a high percentage of fat.
- Sponge means you begin by mixing the yeast with a small amount of flour, sugar, and liquid then you let it ferment for a short time before you mix in the rest of the ingredients. This allows the yeast to hydrate, not battle the sugar for water and helps develop flavor.
- High Fat means you’ll start off with a sponge and then add all of the ingredients except the fat. You’ll knead the dough until the dough passes the windowpane stage (you’ll grab a small piece of dough and begin to stretch it out thin. You should be able to see through it similar to how you would look through a pane of glass. The dough should not have any tears). If it passes that test then you’ll slowly add room temperature butter in.
Here are some of my enriched dough recipes:
Super Soft ‘n Chewy Hoagie Rolls
Now get your buns into the kitchen and start baking! Let’s see your breads! Make sure to tag me in your pictures or use hashtag #thekitchenwhisperer so I can see your deliciousness!
Yes, but–Procedurally, how do I incorporate the enrichment materials & change the proofing period and temps? For instance, if I were to start with a baguette dough and want to convert half into ciabatta, or began with pizza dough, and want to make a portion of it cinnamon rolls, you get the idea.
So this post was to explain just the difference between lean and enriched doughs. Each type of item you describe above uses different measurements and ingredients. Like my pizza dough doesn’t use sugar or dairy like I would in cinnamon rolls. My advice is to make individual recipes.
Best Kitchen Wishes!
Between lean and enhanced loaf, which one has a longer shelves life span
Hi! I’m doing some research and testing on this as I’ve honestly never given it a thought. Bread, lean or enriched never lasts long in my house. As soon as I find out, I’ll let you know my findings. Great question!
Best Kitchen Wishes!
Would zucchini bread be considered rich or lean dough?
Hi!
Great question! No zucchini bread, banana bread and the like are known as “Quick breads”. While they contain fats like an enriched dough would, they do not contain yeast and are technically not a dough but rather a batter.
There is no proofing involved.
Best Kitchen Wishes!
why lean breads bake at a higher temperature than enriched breads
Lean doughs are lighter so then can handle to the higher temps. Because enriched doughs are heavier, if you try to bake it at a higher temp, the crust would brown, the inside would be raw and you wouldn’t have much height.
Best Kitchen Wishes!
I don’t believe this is strictly the reason – enriched doughs have fat throughout, and since fat has a much lower heat capacity than water, the heat of the oven can do a much better job of penetrating the dough early in the baking process. Lean doughs need to be cooked at a high temperature because the heat has trouble penetrating to the center of the loaf.
It’s the same reason you coat lean meat like chicken breasts in oil before baking – it helps the heat penetrate more quickly.
Thank you for expanding on what I said! My “more stuff in it” was in reference to the fat and dairy thus making it more heavy.
You’re right. As hard as I do my best, I sometimes don’t think that “more stuff in it” would immediately make folks think “oh, she means fats and so forth.” Thank you for clarifying! I really appreciate it!
Best Kitchen Wishes!
I make your artisan no knead bread all the time and I love it