• FB
  • Insta
  • Pinterest
  • X
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Amazon
  • Home
  • About
  • Recipe
    Index
The Kitchen Whisperer
  • Tuesday’s
    Tips
  • Weekly
    Menu
  • Shop
  • Recipe Index
  • Shop
  • Weekly Menu
  • Tuesday’s Tips
Jun 4 2019

How to pick a perfect watermelon

Find the recipe card at the end of the post. Make sure to read the content as it contains chef tips, substitution options, and answers to FAQs to help you succeed the first time around!

Posts may contain affiliate links that help enable me to continue to provide you with free recipes. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please see my Privacy Policy for details.

Jump to Recipe

Picking the perfect watermelon is made super easy when you follow these chef tips! Summer just isn’t summer without fresh, juicy, sweet watermelon!

Now when it comes to picking out a watermelon the I’ve seen folks shake it, sniff it, whack it, poke it, prod it, hold it up to the light and everything in between when it comes to picking that perfect watermelon. Heck I’ve seen people literally set it on the grocery store floor and roll it. When I asked the guy why he did that he said “if it wobbles and doesn’t flip sides it means it’s fresh”. Um… <blink blink.. huh?>. Yeah, I won’t be telling you to do that nor would I honestly advise that but hey if a wobbly watermelon works for you, who am I to judge…much. <love you>

Picking the perfect watermelon is made super easy when you follow these chef tips! Summer just isn't summer without fresh, juicy, sweet watermelon!

Ripe, juicy watermelons is what summer is all about. This has always been for me the true beginning of summer. Now granted most grocery stores carry them in the store year round buuuuuuuuuuut living in Pittsburgh I know that farm-fresh watermelons are in season from late May to August.

So let’s talk about how to pick the perfect watermelon. It’s honestly pretty straight forward and for me, works every time.

Field Spot

When watermelons grow on the ground they pretty much stay put other than getting larger and fatter. They don’t roll around and you really don’t move them. So as a watermelon grows, the part touching the ground is known as the field spot. It tends to be a various shade of yellow. The more golden, creamy yellow the spot is AND the larger that spot is, the more the fruit has stayed long enough on the vine to become ripe. If the spot is small or white/pale green it’s under-ripe which means your melon will be bitter and pretty gross to be honest.

Brown spots/webbing

This is something I learned when I was wee little as we used to farm watermelons. I used to think the brown webbing/scars were bad but I was wrong. Those are actually caused during pollination and growth on the flowers of the watermelon plant. When the bees pollinate the flowers the brown webbing/scarring occurs. THIS IS A GOOD THING! The more webbing, the sweeter the melon.

How heavy it is

You want a watermelon that is heavy in weight for its size. The heavier it is, the more juice it has inside. If you pick up a ginormous one and it’s light as a feather, put it back. It means it’s too old and starting to lose moisture.

Knock it

Yep, you read that right, knock on it. It should have a deep, hollow sound when you knock on the underside. If you knock on it and it’s just a thud sound don’t get it. When a watermelon has been harvested too soon OR it’s over ripe (remember the whole light melon?) the melon will have a dull sound.

Do you salt your watermelon? I do!

Once you grab it, take it home, rinse it off and enjoy!  What’s your favorite watermelon dish? For me just give me fresh watermelon and salt. Yes… salt. For me, it brings out the natural sweetness of the fruit. Oh quit making that face. You put salt in desserts, don’t you?

Here are some of my favorite recipes featuring watermelon or that pair beautifully with it!

♥ Grilled Watermelon Caprese Skewers
♥ Stuffed Banana Peppers
♥ Instant Pot BBQ Jelly Chicken
♥ Luscious Watermelon & Pineapple Salsa
♥ Chicken Barbacoa Soft Tacos
♥ Honey & Garlic Broiled Flank Steak
♥ Sweet Potato Chipotle Lettuce Cups
♥ Instant Pot Pulled Pork
♥ Southwest Turkey Burgers with Roasted Tomatillo Salsa Verde

Print

How to pick a perfect watermelon

Picking the perfect watermelon is made super easy when you follow these chef tips! Summer just isn't summer without fresh, juicy, sweet watermelon!
Print Recipe
Save Recipe Recipe Saved

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

5 from 2 reviews

Picking the perfect watermelon is made super easy when you follow these chef tips! Summer just isn’t summer without fresh, juicy, sweet watermelon!

  • Author: TKWAdmin

Ingredients

Fresh Watermelon

Instructions

Field Spot

  1. Look for the creamy, yellow large field spot on the underside of the melon. The more golden, creamy yellow the spot is AND the larger that spot is, the more the fruit has stayed long enough on the vine to become ripe. If the spot is small or white/pale green it’s under-ripe which means your melon will be bitter and pretty gross to be honest.

Brown spots/webbing

  1. Look for brown webbing – this indicates sweetness. This is actually caused during pollination and growth on the flowers of the watermelon plant. When the bees pollinate the flowers the brown webbing/scarring occurs. THIS IS A GOOD THING! The more webbing, the sweeter the melon.

How heavy it is

  1. You want a heavy one! This is when being heavy is a good thing! The heavier it is, the more juice it has inside. If you pick up a ginormous one and it’s light as a feather, put it back. It means it’s too old and starting to lose moisture.

Knock it

  1. Tap the melon. Yep, you read that right, knock on it. It should have a deep, hollow sound when you knock on the underside. If you knock on it and it’s just a thud sound don’t get it.

Made this recipe?

Tag @thekitchenwhisperer on Instagram and hashtag it #thekitchenwhisperer

Save For Later!

Make it a meal!

Pairs Perfectly With:

  • Chicken Barbacoa Soft Tacos

    Chicken Barbacoa Soft Tacos

  • Honey Garlic Broiled Flank Steak

    Honey Garlic Broiled Flank Steak

  • Spicy Watermelon & Pineapple Salsa

    Spicy Watermelon & Pineapple Salsa

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

7 responses

  1. Sheri L.
    July 22, 2025

    Yes, I always look for the brown “sap” like marks on the outside of the watermelon. Usually, if they have them, then they are super sweet.

    Another funny tip that someone just recently told me is look for the watermelons with a small “butthole” lol. Basically one end will be where it’s connected to the vine, so if you look at the other end, make sure the spot is as small as possible. I haven’t tested this one out though haha

    Reply
    1. Lori
      July 22, 2025

      Yep, the button/butt part should be as small as possible. The smaller it is, the longer it’s been left on the vine.

      Best Kitchen Wishes!

      Reply
  2. Rick Reed
    June 5, 2019

    Does the same hold true for other melons such as cantaloupe and honey dews?

    Reply
    1. TKWAdmin
      June 5, 2019

      Hi Rick!

      For the most part yes but with another additional thing to check. Cantaloupes also have a “sweet spot”. I wrote a Tuesday’s tip a while back about how to pick the perfect one!

      Tuesday’s Tip with The Kitchen Whisperer – How to Buy Cantaloupe

      Best Kitchen Wishes!

      Reply
  3. Jo Wilson
    June 4, 2019

    Love this Lori! Very informative!

    Reply
    1. TKWAdmin
      June 5, 2019

      Thank you Jo!

      Reply
  4. Charlie
    June 4, 2019

    I needed this so badly as I am terrible at picking out watermelon. You’re the best Lori! Thank you!

    Reply

Welcome!

I’m Lori, The Kitchen Whisperer®! Let me help you tame the kitchen one bite at a time.

More about Lori

Let’s be friends

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • X
  • TikTok
  • YouTube

Legend


AF Air Fryer B Base Recipes BBQ BBQ Method FM Freezer Meals IP Instant Pot MP Meal Prep O Oven Method PF Party Foods SC Slow Cooker S Smoker Method

Deliciousness Delivered.

Sign up to receive delicious recipes, kitchen tips and weekly menus (bacon, pizza, & BBQ oh my!) straight to your inbox.

Click to Subscribe
Text: this week's menu

Subscribe for delicious new recipes, kitchen tips & weekly menus

Join the TKW Family

What’s trending on TKW

  • Best Super Soft and Chewy Hoagie Rolls
  • Mom’s Classic Easy Stuffed Cabbage Rolls – The Best Recipe!
  • The Ultimate Slow Baked Boneless Short Ribs Recipe
  • Authentic Belgian Waffle Recipe
  • Best Ever Pork Roast and Sauerkraut
  • The Best Portabella Mushroom Veggie Burgers
  • Easy and Juicy Cornish Game Hens
  • 45 Easy & Delicious Pellet Smoker Recipes
  • Smoked Hot Honey Butter Spatchcock Chicken
Back to Top
Recipe Index
Instagram feed
Contact
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • X
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Amazon